Siesta Key Homes for Sale & Real Estate Listings

As of mid-2025, the average home price in Siesta Key, FL ranges from $1 million to $3 million, depending on property size, location, and proximity to the beach. Luxury waterfront estates and Gulf-front condos tend to command higher prices, while smaller inland homes and condos offer more affordable options.

Popular neighborhoods in Siesta Key include Siesta Isles, known for its canal-front homes; Sarasota Beach, located near the lively Siesta Key Village; and Turtle Beach, ideal for those seeking a quieter, more laid-back vibe. The Sanderling Club offers exclusive, gated luxury living, while Bay Island provides convenient access to downtown Sarasota.

When buying a home in Siesta Key, consider factors like flood zones, elevation, beach access, rental restrictions, and proximity to shops and dining. It's also important to review maintenance needs for older or waterfront properties, as well as potential rental income if you plan to use the home as an investment or vacation rental.

Homes in Siesta Key often feature open floor plans, private pools, expansive lanais, and gulf or bay views. Many properties boast boat docks, elevators, gourmet kitchens, and updated finishes. Condos typically offer resort-style amenities such as beach access, fitness centers, tennis courts, and community pools.

Yes, many homes and condos in Siesta Key are part of HOA communities, especially within gated neighborhoods and condominium complexes. HOA fees vary by property and can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars annually, covering services such as landscaping, security, common area maintenance, and beach or dock access.