10 Best Restaurants in Sarasota, FL

Sarasota, Florida, is known for its stunning beaches, vibrant arts scene, and thriving culinary landscape. From fresh seafood to international cuisines, the city offers a diverse range of dining options that cater to all palates and preferences. Whether you're a local or a visitor, exploring the best restaurants in Sarasota is a delightful journey through flavors and culinary innovation. Here's a guide to some of the top dining establishments that define the dining scene in this charming coastal city.

Situated in the heart of downtown Sarasota, Selva stands out with its innovative Peruvian cuisine, blending traditional flavors with modern culinary techniques. This chic, lively spot is celebrated for its meticulously crafted ceviche and specialty pisco cocktails. Signature dishes like the Skirt Steak Anticucho and Seafood Risotto are testaments to Selva's creative culinary approach, making it a must-visit for those seeking a unique dining experience in Sarasota.

Capturing the essence of old Florida, Owen's Fish Camp in the historic Burns Court district offers a laid-back setting reminiscent of a southern fish camp. Here, the charm of the South is evident in both the ambiance and the menu, with dishes like Low Country Boil and Southern Fried Catfish taking center stage. The rustic outdoor seating under a grand banyan tree adds to the authentic experience, making it a favorite for seafood lovers and those seeking a taste of Southern hospitality.

A champion of local seafood, Duval's prides itself on serving the freshest catches with a flair for innovation. This acclaimed restaurant is a cornerstone of Sarasota's dining scene, offering a menu that highlights the best of the Gulf Coast. Favorites include the Duval’s Seafood Sampler and Lobster Mac & Cheese, which are enhanced by a sophisticated, welcoming atmosphere that invites diners to enjoy top-tier seafood in the heart of the city.

Family-owned and operated, Libby's brings a contemporary touch to American dining with a menu catering to various tastes. Situated in a chic, modern setting, the restaurant offers everything from succulent steaks and gourmet burgers to lighter fare like salads and small plates. Libby's is a gathering place for those who enjoy vibrant atmospheres and diverse American cuisine, making it a staple in Sarasota’s dining landscape.

For authentic American BBQ, Brick's Smoked Meats is the go-to destination in downtown Sarasota. Embracing the art of low and slow cooking, Brick's serves up Texas-style smoked meats that are rich in flavor. The Brisket and Pulled Pork, favorites among regulars, are best enjoyed with sides like jalapeño cheddar sausage and classic mac 'n cheese. Brick’s not only offers great food but also a lively setting where diners can indulge in true American barbecue.

Established in 1905, Columbia Restaurant is Florida's oldest restaurant and a landmark of Spanish and Cuban cuisine in Sarasota. The restaurant's historic charm is the perfect backdrop for its menu of traditional favorites, including the famous "1905" Salad and Paella "Valenciana." Columbia's commitment to authenticity and quality has made it a beloved destination for generations of diners seeking a genuine taste of Spanish heritage in Florida.

Chef Steve Phelps, a James Beard Award nominee, makes Indigenous a standout with his focus on sustainable and locally sourced ingredients. The menu at Indigenous changes with the seasons, reflecting the best local produce and seafood available. Dishes like the Wild Mushroom Bisque and Gulf Grouper illustrate the restaurant’s commitment to environmental stewardship and culinary excellence. Dining at Indigenous offers a thoughtful, delicious exploration of Sarasota's natural bounty.

Drunken Poet Cafe brings the best of Thai and Japanese cuisines to Sarasota with a diverse menu that includes everything from sushi to classic Thai dishes like Pad Thai and Green Curry. The intimate setting and artistic decor provide a warm atmosphere for enjoying flavorful, carefully prepared dishes. Drunken Poet's blend of traditional and modern Asian cooking makes it a favorite for locals and tourists alike.

Element: Steak. Seafood. Pasta. offers a sophisticated dining experience focused on these three core offerings. Located in a stylish and modern space, Element impresses with its array of carefully prepared steaks, fresh seafood, and handmade pasta. Each dish is crafted with precision, making Element a go-to for those seeking a high-quality dining experience in Sarasota. Its elegant ambiance is perfect for a special evening out, emphasizing a commitment to fine ingredients and exceptional flavors.

Antoine's Restaurant provides a luxurious dining experience with its European-inspired menu and refined setting. Known for its impeccable service and gourmet offerings, Antoine’s specializes in dishes like Escargot and Veal Piccata. The restaurant’s atmosphere and high culinary standards make it an ideal choice for those looking for an upscale dining experience in Sarasota.

Each Sarasota restaurant brings its unique flavor and style, making the city a true paradise for food lovers. From casual eateries to upscale dining, Sarasota’s restaurant scene is as diverse as it is impressive. Whether you are seeking a memorable meal or a casual bite, the culinary delights of Sarasota promise a delicious dining experience.

If you're captivated by the culinary richness of Sarasota, FL, and are considering making this wonderful city your home, look no further than The RSTS Group. Their team of dedicated professionals is ready to help you find the perfect property that meets your needs and exceeds your expectations. Whether you're looking for a cozy beachfront condo or a luxurious estate, they have the expertise and local knowledge of Sarasota real estate to guide you through every step of the home-buying process. Contact The RSTS Group today to start your journey to a new home in beautiful Sarasota.